Is your Rheem Criterion II gas furnace acting up and leaving you in the cold? You rely on your furnace to keep your home warm and comfortable, especially when the temperatures drop.
When it stops working properly, it can be frustrating and stressful. But don’t worry—you’re not alone, and fixing it might be easier than you think. In this guide, you’ll find simple, step-by-step troubleshooting tips that anyone can follow. Keep reading to get your furnace back in top shape and enjoy a cozy home again.
Common Rheem Criterion Ii Issues
The Rheem Criterion II gas furnace is a reliable heating system. Still, like all furnaces, it can have some common problems. Recognizing these issues early helps keep your home warm and safe. This section covers the typical problems you might face with this furnace model.
No Heat Production
The furnace runs but does not produce heat. This issue might come from a faulty thermostat, a gas supply problem, or a dirty burner. Checking the pilot light and gas valve can help identify the cause. Sometimes, a blocked air filter stops warm air flow.
Frequent Cycling
The furnace turns on and off too often. This can waste energy and wear out parts faster. Causes include a dirty air filter, incorrect thermostat settings, or an oversized furnace. Poor airflow or a failing limit switch might also cause rapid cycling.
Unusual Noises
Strange sounds like banging, rattling, or squealing may come from the furnace. Loose parts, a dirty blower motor, or a failing belt cause these noises. Ignoring sounds can lead to bigger problems. Regular maintenance helps prevent noisy operation.
Pilot Light Problems
The pilot light will not stay lit or does not light at all. This usually happens due to a dirty pilot tube, faulty thermocouple, or gas supply issues. Checking and cleaning the pilot assembly often solves the problem. A weak flame can also cause heating failure.
Thermostat Malfunctions
The furnace does not respond properly to thermostat commands. This may be due to incorrect wiring, low batteries, or an old thermostat. A malfunctioning thermostat can cause no heat or constant running. Testing the thermostat can confirm if replacement is needed.

Credit: www.springcanyon.org
Basic Troubleshooting Steps
Basic troubleshooting steps help you solve common problems with your Rheem Criterion II gas furnace. These simple checks often fix issues without calling a technician. Follow each step carefully to keep your furnace running smoothly and safely.
Checking The Power Supply
Start by ensuring your furnace has power. Check the circuit breaker or fuse box for any tripped switches or blown fuses. Make sure the furnace’s power switch is turned on. No power means the furnace cannot work.
Inspecting The Air Filter
Look at the furnace’s air filter. A dirty or clogged filter blocks airflow. This makes the furnace work harder and can cause it to shut down. Replace the filter if it looks dirty. Clean filters improve efficiency and air quality.
Resetting The Furnace
Locate the reset button on your Rheem Criterion II furnace. Press it gently to restart the system. This can clear minor faults. Wait a few minutes after pressing reset before checking if the furnace runs properly again.
Verifying Thermostat Settings
Check your thermostat settings. Make sure it is set to “Heat” mode and the temperature is higher than the room’s current temperature. Incorrect settings stop the furnace from turning on. Adjust settings if needed to ensure comfort.
Fixing Ignition Problems
Ignition problems are common issues with Rheem Criterion II gas furnaces. These problems stop the furnace from lighting up properly. Fixing ignition issues helps restore warmth and comfort quickly. The main parts to check include the igniter and the flame sensor. These parts work together to start the burner safely. Troubleshooting these components can often solve ignition troubles without calling a technician.
Cleaning The Igniter
A dirty igniter can fail to spark. Dust and debris block the electric current. Turn off power to the furnace first. Use a soft brush to clean the igniter gently. Avoid using water or harsh chemicals. Cleaning restores the igniter’s ability to light the gas. This simple step often fixes the ignition problem.
Replacing The Igniter
If cleaning does not help, the igniter might be faulty. Igniters wear out over time and stop working. Purchase a replacement igniter designed for Rheem Criterion II models. Turn off the furnace power before starting. Remove the old igniter carefully, noting its position. Install the new igniter and secure it properly. Test the furnace to see if it lights up. A new igniter often solves persistent ignition issues.
Checking The Flame Sensor
The flame sensor detects if the burner is lit. A dirty or faulty sensor can stop the furnace from running. Turn off the power and remove the flame sensor. Clean the metal rod gently with fine sandpaper or steel wool. Reinstall the sensor and turn on the furnace. If cleaning fails, replace the sensor. This step ensures the furnace runs safely and efficiently.

Credit: www.springcanyon.org
Resolving Airflow Issues
Airflow problems in your Rheem Criterion II gas furnace can cause uneven heating and higher energy bills. These issues often result from simple blockages or settings. Fixing airflow ensures your home stays warm and comfortable. Check vents, blower motor, and fan settings to restore proper flow.
Clearing Blocked Vents
Blocked vents stop warm air from moving through your home. Dust, furniture, or curtains can cover vents. Remove any obstacles near each vent. Use a vacuum to clean dust and debris inside vents. Clear vents help air flow smoothly and heat your rooms evenly.
Inspecting The Blower Motor
The blower motor pushes warm air through your furnace. Dirt buildup can slow it down or stop it. Turn off power before checking the motor. Look for dirt on the fan blades and motor housing. Clean gently with a soft brush or cloth. A clean blower motor runs better and improves airflow.
Adjusting The Fan Settings
Fan settings control how air circulates in your home. The Rheem Criterion II has options like “Auto” and “On.” “Auto” runs the fan only when heating is needed. “On” runs the fan all the time. Set the fan to “Auto” to save energy and keep airflow balanced. Check your furnace manual for exact steps.
Dealing With Error Codes
Dealing with error codes on your Rheem Criterion II gas furnace can help you fix problems faster. These codes show what issue your furnace faces. Understanding these codes saves time and avoids extra repair costs. You can often handle simple issues on your own.
Locating The Diagnostic Led
The diagnostic LED is a small light on the furnace control board. It blinks to show error codes. Open the furnace access panel carefully to find it. The light usually sits near the gas valve or control board. Watch the light flashes closely to read the code.
Common Error Codes And Meanings
Error code 1 means the furnace failed to ignite. Code 2 signals a flame loss during operation. Code 3 shows a pressure switch problem. Code 4 indicates a limit switch is open. Code 5 warns of a flame rollout. Each code points to a different issue.
Steps To Correct Each Error
For error code 1, check the gas supply and reset the furnace. Code 2 needs a look at the flame sensor; clean it gently. For code 3, inspect the pressure switch and its tubing. Code 4 asks for a limit switch test; replace if faulty. Code 5 requires checking for blocked vents or heat exchanger cracks.
When To Call A Professional
Knowing when to call a professional for your Rheem Criterion II gas furnace saves time and ensures safety. Some issues are simple to fix, but others need expert help. Ignoring serious problems can lead to bigger damage or risk to your home. Understanding when to get a technician involved helps keep your furnace running well.
Safety Concerns
Gas furnaces can be dangerous without proper care. Smelling gas or seeing soot around your furnace means stop using it immediately. These signs need urgent professional attention. Carbon monoxide leaks are another serious risk. Only a trained technician can test and fix these safely.
Complex Repairs
Some furnace problems require special tools and skills. Issues like a broken heat exchanger or faulty control board are not for beginners. Attempting these repairs might cause more damage. A professional has the right experience to diagnose and fix complex faults correctly.
Routine Maintenance Tips
Simple checks help your furnace last longer. Change filters every one to three months to keep air clean. Clear debris around the furnace to allow proper airflow. Regularly check the thermostat for accurate readings. Schedule yearly professional inspections to catch hidden issues early.

Credit: www.luziamataro.com
Frequently Asked Questions
How Do I Reset The Rheem Criterion Ii Gas Furnace?
To reset the furnace, turn off the power switch for 30 seconds. Then, switch it back on to restart the system. This can clear minor errors.
Why Is My Rheem Furnace Not Igniting The Gas?
Check if the gas valve is open and the thermostat is set correctly. Dirty burners or a faulty ignition system may also cause this issue.
What Causes The Rheem Furnace Blower To Run Continuously?
A stuck fan limit switch or thermostat setting can keep the blower on. Inspect these parts and replace if needed to fix the problem.
How Can I Tell If The Rheem Furnace Flame Sensor Is Dirty?
A dirty flame sensor causes the furnace to shut off quickly. Look for flickering flame or frequent shutdowns as signs of a dirty sensor.
Why Does My Rheem Furnace Make Strange Noises?
Noises might come from loose parts, a failing blower motor, or dirty burners. Regular maintenance can help avoid these sounds.
How Often Should I Replace The Rheem Furnace Air Filter?
Replace the air filter every 1 to 3 months. Clean filters improve airflow and keep the furnace running efficiently.
Conclusion
Troubleshooting your Rheem Criterion II gas furnace can save time and money. Start with simple checks like the thermostat and power supply. Keep the furnace clean and inspect parts regularly. Small issues often cause big problems. If the furnace still won’t work, call a professional for help.
Regular care keeps your home warm and safe. Stay patient and follow steps carefully. This way, you can keep your furnace running smoothly all winter.