Full disclosure: we are an Amazon Associate and earn a commission on qualifying purchases made through the links on this page. You pay exactly the same either way.
The Outland Living Portable Propane is the best fire pit for small patios if you want a clean, low-maintenance option, while the East Oak Fuoco 21 is ideal for those who prefer the classic crackle of wood. These pits differ primarily by fuel source, size, and furniture utility.
1. Outland Living Portable Propane Fire Pit
Best for: Someone who wants a clean, instant fire without any cleanup.
This fire pit is designed for those who value convenience and safety. It uses propane to provide a consistent flame, which means you avoid the ash and smoke associated with traditional wood fires. Its compact 19-inch size allows it to fit easily into smaller outdoor areas.
Because it’s CSA-approved, it may be used in many areas where wood-burning fires are restricted, though you should always check local rules. This model doesn’t include the propane tank, so you must purchase that separately to get started.
Good if:
- You want a fire that starts in minutes.
- You need a portable option for camping or patios.
- You want to avoid cleaning up messy ash.
Skip it if:
- You prefer the smell and sound of real wood.
- You don’t want to manage a propane tank.
2. East Oak Fuoco 21 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit
Best for: Someone who wants the experience of a wood fire without the smoke.
The East Oak Fuoco 21 uses an advanced airflow design to increase efficiency, which reduces the amount of smoke produced during a burn. It’s built from stainless steel, which is designed to resist corrosion and handle high heat.
The unit includes a removable ash pan, making it easier to maintain than traditional open pits. It’s a good fit for groups of 4-6 people, providing a social centerpiece that remains compact enough for most backyards.
Good if:
- You love the atmosphere of a wood-burning fire.
- You want a durable stainless steel construction.
- You need a portable design with an included carry bag.
Skip it if:
- You’re strictly looking for a gas-powered heat source.
- You prefer not to handle firewood or store ash.
3. East Oak 28” Outdoor Propane Fire Pit Table
Best for: Someone who needs their fire pit to double as a table.
This model is a dual-purpose piece of furniture that functions as a 52,000 BTU heater and a table. It’s ideal for smaller patios where you might not have room for both a dedicated fireplace and a coffee table.
The design includes a hook-type lid to cover the burner when it isn’t in use, creating a flat surface. It’s built with a steel frame and stainless steel burner, and it’s backed by a 3-year warranty.
Good if:
- You need to save space on a small deck.
- You want an elegant centerpiece for entertaining.
- You value a multi-year warranty for your investment.
Skip it if:
- You want a purely portable, lightweight bowl.
- You don’t have space for a 28-inch permanent fixture.
4. SINGLYFIRE 22 inch Fire Pit
Best for: A first-time buyer wanting a simple, classic wood-burning bowl.
The SINGLYFIRE 22 Inch is a straightforward wood-burning option that focuses on simplicity. It features a heavy-duty steel frame with high-heat paint, designed to handle the elements throughout the seasons.
It includes a mesh spark screen to help contain embers and a poker to manage logs safely. This is a compact choice for small groups, offering a traditional fire experience without complex features.
Good if:
- You want a simple, no-frills wood-burning bowl.
- You have a small patio that needs an intimate focal point.
- You want a lightweight setup that’s easy to move.
Skip it if:
- You’re worried about smoke or ash on your patio.
- You prefer the ease of a propane ignition system.
5. Flame King Mini Tabletop Fire Pit
Best for: Someone with a very small table or limited dining space.
The Flame King Mini is a tabletop fire pit designed for small-scale ambiance. It’s compatible with both propane and butane, making it flexible for different setups. At only 6.5 x 10.75 inches, it fits comfortably on most dining tables.
It’s a clean-burning option that uses lava rocks to create a flickering effect. It’s a specialized tool for creating a cozy vibe during dinner or small gatherings rather than a primary heat source for a large group.
Good if:
- You have extremely limited space for a full pit.
- You want a tabletop centerpiece for s’mores.
- You need a dual-fuel option.
Skip it if:
- You’re looking for significant warmth for a group.
- You don’t have a table with an umbrella hole for proper setup.
Where These Overlap
The Outland Living Portable Propane and the East Oak 28 Propane both offer the convenience of gas, but they serve different roles. The Outland model is built for portability, while the East Oak 28 is a stationary table. Meanwhile, the East Oak Fuoco 21 and the SINGLYFIRE 22 Inch are both wood-burning bowls, but the East Oak model uses airflow technology to minimize smoke. Choosing between them comes down to whether you prioritize the “smokeless” experience or a basic, traditional fire bowl. If you’re indifferent to the smoke, the basic steel bowls are very similar in function.
Still Not Sure?
How often will I really use it?
If you plan to use your fire pit several times a week for quick evening relaxation, a propane model like the Outland Living Portable Propane is usually the best choice. It requires no cleanup, so you can enjoy it without the chore of removing ash after every session.
What do I already own that this has to work with?
Check your patio furniture and available floor space. If you lack a coffee table, the East Oak 28 Propane is a smart way to gain both a fire source and a surface for drinks or snacks. It integrates better into a small seating area than a standalone bowl.
What am I most likely to regret choosing?
Many buyers regret choosing a wood-burning pit for a very small, enclosed patio because of the smoke and drifting ash. If you’re concerned about your neighbors or keeping your space clean, the CSA Group safety standards for gas-fired appliances offer a much cleaner and more predictable experience than open wood fires.
Related guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What does it take to keep these running week to week?
Gas pits require you to monitor your propane levels and replace the tank once empty. Wood-burning pits require you to source firewood and clear out the ash pan or bowl.
Would the more capable one have suited me better?
If you chose a basic wood bowl but find yourself avoiding it because of the smoke, a smokeless model like the East Oak Fuoco 21 might have been a better fit. If you find a tabletop unit too small for your needs, moving to a larger, full-sized table provides more heat and versatility.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right piece for your outdoor space doesn’t have to be a headache. Once you’ve measured your patio, pick the style that fits your lifestyle best. You’ll love how a little warmth transforms your evenings, so go ahead and order your favorite today—you won’t regret making your backyard feel like home.